The ‘Word of Faith Movement’ (WOF) which began in the mid 20th century covers a variety of Christian denominations. It’s teachers are very popular. If you walk into any Christian bookstore (especially in Nigeria), the first 10 books you will likely find are written by these Faith teachers. The movement emphasize faith, the believer’s authority, healing, prosperity, the power of the Spirit and positive confession- which the church today needs.
An article in the Dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic Movements identifies E. W Kenyon as the “founder” and men like Kenneth Hagin, Kenneth Copeland, Charles Capps, Frederick K. C Price, Robert Tilton, Paul Yonggi Cho, Robert Schuller (and some famous preachers in Africa) as disciples. However, as widespread as their teachings are, there are certain doctrinal errors that have crept in which subtly undermines the Bible.
Now, before you dismiss me as a cessationist (one who believes that the gifts of the Spirit have ceased) or as “blinded by traditions,” let me say that I’m well acquainted with Pentecostal tradition and I’ve lived in Word Faith teachings before; I know what they teach. I say this because many Christians resort to funny labels as diversionary tactics whenever unbiblical teachings are exposed.
I’m not the first to address this; great scholars have done so before me. Dr Charles Farah, Professor of Theology and Historical Studies at Oral Roberts University points out that the Word of Faith “movement uses Gnostic hermeneutical principles and displaces contextual scientific exegesis. It shares many of the goals of present day humanism, particularly in regards to the creaturely comforts. It is, in fact, a burgeoning heresy.” (Pneuma: The Journal of the Society for Pentecostal Studies, 1981, 21)
The Faith teachers “twist particular verses out of their plain meaning” says Dr George Wood in his book Mountain Movers, “and they fail to let the Bible speak for itself.”
Chuck Smith of blessed memory made reference to “The latest wind of pernicious, unscriptural doctrine to blow through the ranks of Charismatics is the ‘what-you-say-is-what-you-get’ teaching, otherwise known as the prosperity doctrine…[These] teachings sound more like Mary Baker Eddy [Christian Science] than the Apostle Paul” (Charisma vs Charismania, 135)
I intentionally quoted these leading Pentecostal ministers so that you can see that this analysis is not based on “denominational prejudices” or an “anti-supernatural” trio. Three of the most outspoken critics of the WOF, Hank Hanegraaff, D. R McConnell and David Wilkerson are dye-in-wool Pentecostals. In addition to this, the Word of Faith circle is not even a denomination, therefore I appeal to Christians to lay off unbendable sentiments that replaces discernment with blind belief. Let us reason together from the Scriptures.
The Faith of God
The WOF theology says God is a “faith God” who is bound by laws which operates through the forces of faith. Mark 11:22 “have faith in God” is used as a primary text to support this view and it is argued that the literal Greek says “have the faith of God.” I’m yet to come across any reputable Greek scholar who has rendered this text this way. From my research, no Christian scholar has translated Mk 11:22 in such a way in the past 2,000 years.
They also teach that God had faith in His faith when He spoke the words of creation and we too have the same ability as God to call things into existence. This teaching is so far removed from Mk 11:22. All things were created not because God said it, but because it was God who said it. Nowhere does the Bible teach that faith is a mind power or a force that can be used to control or get anything we want. A real faith lets God be God and trusts in His wisdom (Job 42:1-6, Rom 11:33-36).
“[Adam] was created on terms of equality with God and he could stand in God’s presence without any consciousness of inferiority…He lived on equal terms with God” (Zoe: The God Kind of Life, 33)
Scripture says: “The Lord God took the man and put him in the Garden of Eden to work and take care of it” (Gen 2:15). Adam was only a steward who was to look after the animals God had made and the garden. God told him to rule over all He had made (1:28) but this doesn’t make Adam equal to God because everything on earth still belonged to God. Adam was only a tenant. Even after the Fall, God was still the Owner of the earth “and everything in it, the world and all who live in it” (Ps 24:1). Remember, the idea that Adam is God is a Mormon doctrine.
E. W Kenyon wrote: “The Lord Jesus was not, however, a ‘one-of-a-kind’. ‘Incarnation can be repeated in each and everyone of us. Every man who has been ‘born again’ is an Incarnation.” (The Father and His Family, 100).
Hagin repeated his teachings:
“You are as much the incarnation of God as Jesus Christ was. Every man who has been born again is an incarnation” (Word of Faith, Dec 1980, 14).
But Jesus is the “ONLY begotten Son, which is in the bosom of the Father” (Jh 1:18). He is the “Word made flesh”- a designation given to no other (1:14). We are born by flesh but adopted by God, unlike Jesus who was uniquely begotten by God (Rom 8:15). We cannot bring ourselves on the same level of God or Jesus. Such an idea is heretical.
They teach that Christ’s death on the cross was insufficient to redeem us, that He had to suffer in Hell in the hands of demons (addressed here). This is why Kenyon wrote:
“We have sung ‘Nearer the cross’ and we have prayed that we might be ‘Nearer the cross’ but the cross has no salvation in it. It is a place of failure and defeat.”
On the contrary, “the preaching of the cross” (1Cor 1:18) is crucial to our salvation and victory over Satan. Our pathway to fellowship with God was accomplished “by the cross” (Eph 2:16) and Jesus made “peace through the blood of the cross” (Col 1:20). To displace the cross is to displace redemption.
WOF teach that all sicknesses are from Satan and must be countered by positive confession. In such a case, physical symptoms must be denied and medical attention shunned.
One of them wrote that if he had a headache, he would not tell anyone; and if someone should ask him how he was feeling he would reply “I’m fine thank you.”
Denying the symptoms of headaches or common colds may not have serious implications, but in instances such as cancer, where an early diagnosis is vital in combating the disease, denying the symptoms can make it terminal. Some misled parents have withheld insulin, antibiotics (and medical attention) from their children in the name of “faith” and they ended up dead.
Sicknesses came from the Fall and not all are from Satan. As long as we are in this “lowly body” (Phil 3:21), we will be vulnerable to infection, exhaustion and pain. God heals supernaturally and also through the knowledge He has given to man- doctors are not devils and the use of medicines doesn’t indicate a lack of faith.
The irony of this is that many WOF teachers eat good foods, go for medical check-ups, live in clean environments, go for surgeries, use eye-glasses and do take pills. Why all these precautions if the “God kind of faith” heals all sicknesses? Many of them have actually died under medical care which they had preached against. The faith of many Christians have been shipwrecked by teachers who told them to “positively confess” their dying loved ones to live and the person died.
It is taught that if a believer desires a thing (success, wealth or healing) he must first visualize it in his mind over and over again and then speak it out into existence, and whatever he confesses is what he possesses.
In Scripture, we see a different picture.
Ps 89:19 “Then thou spakest in vision to thy holy one…”
Ez 8:3 “…and the spirit lifted me up between the earth and the heavens and brought me in the visions of God to Jerusalem.”
Ez 11:24 “…and brought me in a vision by the Spirit of God unto Chaldea…”
In the visions these people saw, the pictures were coming from an outside Source- God- they were not images they willfully made up from their own minds.
God condemned false prophets because “they speak a vision of their own heart, and not out of the mouth of the Lord…and they say unto everyone that walketh after the imagination of his heart…” (Jer 23:16-17).
These men were conjuring up a vision or picture from their fleshy hearts, presuming it was the mind of God. This is exactly what visualization is. Its self-will. We cant control God with our minds. Apostle Peter didn’t visualize the conversion of Cornelius neither did Paul visualize himself out of jail. Some of them even teach people to visualize Jesus and then pray to that “image.” But how can you visualize someone you have never physically seen before? This is unbiblical and idolatrous. There are also the false teachings of using the “laws of miracles” addressed here.
Many Christians try to defend Word-Faith teachers by stating that they do teach the Bible. That is true. In fact, you can listen to these teachers for 30 mins and not hear anything unbiblical. But there is often a twist, a subtle introduction of aberrant teachings cloaked with a-contextual Bible verses. But how much error is required before a person’s theology can be labelled as ‘dangerous’ and disposed of?
Besides, many of these teachers try to safeguard themselves from any Biblical scrutiny by accusing those who question their heresies of “touching the Lord’s anointed.” They may say God will get angry at such people or they will die. For example, in the book I Believe in Visions, the authors says that Jesus told him that those pastors who don’t accept his prophetic word will die in their pulpits! (p 114). Like the late Paul Crouch of TBN (where WOF teachings are disseminated) once flipped out at his Christian critics:
“I think God has given up on a lot of old, rotten Sanhedrin religious crowd, twice dead, plucked from the roots…the heresy hunters that want to find a little mote of illegal doctrine in some Christian’s eye…I say to hell with you!…quit blocking God’s bridges or God’s gonna shoot you if I don’t!…I don’t even want to talk to you or hear you. I don’t want to see your ugly face!…” (Praise the Lord #Transcript)
No preacher or teacher, no matter how anointed or popular should be too “exalted” to be corrected. Only God is infallible. If a person is reading into the Word of God something that is not there, or which is inconsistent with sound exegesis, we must challenge or expose that error and point out to the brethren who these mistaken teacher are. Unfortunately, many “Faith teachers” are yet to admit to these heresies let alone repent of them. The excuse is they came by “revelation knowledge” and must not be questioned. Scripture says “Take heed unto thyself and unto the doctrine; continue in them; for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself and them that hear thee.” (1Tim 4:16).
Many Christians are unwilling to test these doctrines sometimes due to blind devotion. Some African preachers do not even realize the extent of falsehood mixed into what they gleaned from a best selling author or Christian media before teaching their congregation. However, God wants us to test all doctrines, no matter how popular, and hold on to the good (1Thess 5:21).